The Rings of Power: All That Money. Where’s the Soul?
THE REVIEW OBSESSION · PART 2 OF 7
Amazon can buy an enormous Middle-earth. It cannot buy the moment when a character makes you care.
That’s the frustrating contradiction of The Rings of Power. I can stare at the landscapes, costumes and elaborate sets and see how seriously the production takes Tolkien’s world. Then a supposedly devastating turn arrives and I find myself admiring the lighting instead of feeling the loss.
The problem isn’t that the show has money. The problem is the belief that visual magnitude can generate emotional magnitude. It can’t. You can put thousands of extras in front of a spectacular fortress, but if the person defending it isn’t convincing, the battle is still just movement on a screen.
The real cost of looking expensive
Fantasy asks audiences to accept an impossible world. It achieves that not by making every stone photorealistic but by creating a sense that people have lived there. Tolkien’s world is built out of history, language, friendship, loyalty, corruption and small decisions that become catastrophes. The landscape matters because those lives matter inside it.
Think about why the quieter moments in Peter Jackson’s films stay with people: ordinary characters choosing whether to be brave; friendship under pressure; a piece of music arriving at precisely the right moment. The armies and special effects work because the emotional stakes are already clear. The scene does not need to announce that it is important.
The Rings of Power sometimes reverses that relationship. The camera says, Look how monumental this is, before the writing has earned the feeling. When everything has the shape of an epic moment, very little feels intimate.
Changing Tolkien isn’t the real crime
Adaptations have to change things. Different mediums demand compression, invention and new emphasis. The honest critique is not “they changed the books, therefore the series is bad.” That is a refusal to talk about filmmaking. The stronger question is what the new choice adds.
If a character makes a surprising decision, have we seen enough to believe it? If an alliance falls apart, did the series let us understand the trust that existed first? If a revelation is supposed to hurt, have we spent time with the people it affects? These are practical storytelling questions, not demands for religious obedience to source material.
That is where I understand much of The Critical Drinker’s frustration with the series. The concern about writing and character motivation is worth debating. It doesn’t obligate me to agree with everything he says, and it certainly doesn’t mean somebody who enjoys the show is lying.
Season 3 made the argument more interesting
Season 3 arrived in November 2026, and it would be lazy to say every critic had the same opinion. TheWrap found a darker, more focused season, with the creation of the One Ring giving the drama a stronger center. RogerEbert.com saw ambition undermined by too many competing storylines. The Guardian suggested the improvements arrived too late for a show that had already tested patience.
Those aren’t interchangeable verdicts. One reviewer sees a creative correction; another sees an overstuffed structure that still doesn’t solve the central issue. The Rotten Tomatoes critical roundup captures that divide. The point is to confront the reasons, not cherry-pick the most dramatic headline.
A story can improve. A season can focus its characters. But the viewers asked to return for another season are carrying a history: previous disappointments, abandoned storylines and characters they never warmed to. A better third act doesn’t automatically make the first two acts compelling.
Why some viewers genuinely love it
The series offers something smaller productions rarely can: a lavish, sustained visual journey through Middle-earth. Some viewers enjoy the mythology, performances and the opportunity to live with these locations for hours. Others value the slower, more tragic focus on Sauron and the long consequences of power. That’s not a failure of taste.
There is also a danger in judging every fantasy series against childhood memories of Jackson’s trilogy. Those films have had years to become personal landmarks. The new show is competing with the work itself and everything it represents to its audience. We should acknowledge that disadvantage without treating it as immunity from criticism.
Big budgets are not a storytelling exemption
The question that bothers me goes beyond Amazon. When a franchise becomes a huge commercial machine, its continued existence can feel almost guaranteed. Marketing promises bigger battles and higher stakes. Meanwhile, a smaller original series may never receive a second chance.
Money buys production. It buys time, locations, technicians, beautiful visual effects and a chance to be ambitious. It cannot replace a script that understands why a friendship breaks, why a betrayal hurts or why the audience should dread what happens next.
Don’t show me a thousand people on a battlefield if you haven’t given me one person to worry about. That’s the feeling missing from too many of these enormous spectacles.
The Review Obsession · Part 2 of 7 — a PYLCROW series about how we praise, hate, defend and sometimes rethink entertainment.
Previous: GTA 6: Who’s Afraid of an Honest Review?. Read next: When Being Disappointed Becomes the Business. Start the series from Part 1.

