The Game Awards 2026: Our GOTY Picks, and the GTA 6 Problem
Smart summary
The Game Awards 2026 Game of the Year nominees are official: Grand Theft Auto VI, Resident Evil Requiem, The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, Phantom Blade Zero, CONTROL Resonant and 007 First Light. Our personal top three are Resident Evil 9, Zelda and Phantom Blade Zero. But GTA VI’s eight nominations before its November 19 public release raise a bigger question: should Game of the Year reward sheer scale, or the quality of the experience?
We got the list for The Game Awards 2026, and it’s looking good. Really good.
Rockstar’s gigantic open world. Capcom’s survival-horror powerhouse. Nintendo bringing back one of gaming’s most important adventures. A blistering martial-arts contender. A wonderfully strange Remedy sequel. And James Bond trying to make us feel like 007.
Six games with six very different ideas of what makes gaming special. So how exactly are we supposed to choose the best one?
For the official lineup and nominations, see Gematsu’s full 2026 nominees list. The ceremony takes place December 10, 2026.
The Game Awards 2026 Game of the Year nominees
- Grand Theft Auto VI — Rockstar Games
- Resident Evil Requiem (Resident Evil 9) — Capcom
- The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time — Nintendo
- Phantom Blade Zero — S-GAME
- CONTROL Resonant — Remedy Entertainment
- 007 First Light — IO Interactive
It’s the sort of shortlist that sounds almost impossible on paper. And the debate gets better the closer you look.
Resident Evil 9 already has a GOTY trophy. It doesn’t have this one.

Earlier this month, Resident Evil Requiem won Ultimate Game of the Year at the Golden Joystick Awards. We celebrated that win in our Resident Evil 9 GOTY article, and we stand by it: Capcom understands the power of tension, pacing and a game that knows exactly what it wants to be.
But the Golden Joysticks and The Game Awards aren’t the same ceremony. The Golden Joysticks’ top prize comes from a public vote. The Game Awards combines 90% jury voting and 10% public voting for its main awards, as explained in the event’s official rules.
And Capcom’s Golden Joystick victory was far from a landslide. Reported voting totals put Resident Evil at 17%, Phantom Blade Zero at 16% and Crimson Desert at 15%. That’s a one-percentage-point margin over the game that came second. The voting results make for fascinating reading.
The trophy is deserved. But December is a different fight, against a different field, under a different judging system.
GTA 6 is huge. Is that the same thing as being the best?

We love Grand Theft Auto. Freedom, chaos, ridiculous side missions and the joy of setting out to do one thing before getting distracted for three hours. Rockstar builds places we want to lose ourselves in.
And GTA VI may be an extraordinary achievement. But it has already collected eight Game Awards nominations, including Game of the Year, before its November 19 public release. That isn’t against the rules: the awards’ eligibility deadline is November 20, and jury members may have advance review access. We already explored the timing in our report on how GTA 6 can be nominated before most players get it.
Here’s our problem with the conversation, not necessarily with the nomination: a bigger map isn’t better level design. More missions aren’t automatically better pacing. A bigger budget isn’t inherently a better experience.
A carefully crafted 15-hour game might stay with you longer than an enormous 100-hour adventure. And an enormous adventure might be so consistently inventive that it deserves everything.
We should be open to both possibilities. What we shouldn’t do is award points for scale before the work has been properly judged. Rockstar’s reputation is a reason to be excited, not a substitute for playing the game.
Preparing to jump in? Our GTA 6 final-week guide covers the launch, and our PS5 vs PS5 Pro vs Xbox comparison helps with the hardware question.
What Game Awards history tells us about the winner

We’ve seen this argument before. The Game Awards’ history doesn’t give us a formula, but it does offer a useful reminder: the biggest spectacle doesn’t always win.
| Year | GOTY winner | What it showed |
|---|---|---|
| 2018 | God of War | It beat the enormous open-world achievement of Red Dead Redemption 2. |
| 2023 | Baldur’s Gate 3 | An ambitious RPG prevailed in a year that also featured Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom. |
| 2024 | Astro Bot | A focused, joyful platformer won against far bigger-looking productions. |
| 2025 | Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 | A new IP could command the room without decades of franchise history behind it. |
Those results, documented in GameSpot’s historical Game of the Year winners list, don’t prove that small is better than big. God of War and Baldur’s Gate 3 were hardly modest productions themselves.
What they show is that voters can reward creative coherence, emotional impact, invention and technical excellence without automatically handing the trophy to the largest open world.
That’s good news for almost everyone in this year’s shortlist.
Pylcrow’s top three Game of the Year picks
1. Resident Evil Requiem — our pick to win

Resident Evil doesn’t need a thousand distractions. It needs dread, risk, memorable locations and the confidence to make players uncomfortable. Requiem’s strength is that those choices feel purposeful.
It’s our first pick because execution matters. There is something powerful about a game that knows what it is, then delivers on that promise without chasing every trend.
Want to get into it before the next round of awards? See our Resident Evil 9 catch-up and DLC guide.
2. The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time — nostalgia has to earn its place

The 1998 original helped establish what a modern 3D adventure could feel like. Nintendo’s new Switch 2 version has the reputation of a legend behind it, which is both an advantage and a problem.
It deserves to compete on the strength of the new experience, not because voters loved the original decades ago. And yes, remakes are eligible for the awards when the jury decides that their creative and technical work warrants consideration.
The real question is whether the 2026 game can make new players feel the same sense of discovery that made the original famous. Our comparison of Ocarina of Time’s original N64 limitations and remake changes explores why this matters.
3. Phantom Blade Zero — don’t sleep on this one

Maybe the most interesting challenger of the three. Phantom Blade Zero combines martial-arts choreography, dramatic presentation and a strong identity. And that near-tie with Resident Evil at the Golden Joysticks proves it has passionate support.
Spectacular combat footage is one thing; keeping the player engaged over an entire campaign is another. That’s what separates an impressive showcase from an exceptional game.
But if the fight for GOTY becomes about memorable design rather than sheer scale, this is precisely the kind of contender that could upset a favorite. We’ve covered its strengths and weak spots in our Phantom Blade Zero review roundup.
And don’t write off CONTROL Resonant or 007 First Light

Remedy’s CONTROL Resonant has the confidence to be strange. Its reality-bending world and distinctive presentation are exactly the sort of artistic signatures that can make a game unforgettable. An award should make room for that kind of originality, provided the experience holds together. More details are available from Remedy’s official game site.

007 First Light, meanwhile, brings stealth, cinematic action and an origin story into one package. A Bond game doesn’t have to outspend Rockstar to matter. It has to make the fantasy of being Bond genuinely fun. IO Interactive’s official 007 page shows the approach it’s taking.
Neither is in our top three today, but a shortlist this strong deserves more than a three-game conversation.
So how should we actually measure Game of the Year?
We don’t think there’s a perfect mathematical score for something as personal as gaming. But there’s a better conversation than asking which one has the most content.
| Question | What we’re really judging |
|---|---|
| Did it deliver on its promise? | A horror game should scare; an open world should make freedom meaningful. |
| Are its best ideas well executed? | Depth and polish count more than a checklist of features. |
| Does it have a distinct voice? | Strong design, direction and identity matter, even when ideas aren’t entirely new. |
| Can it sustain the experience? | Great early hours don’t excuse repetition, padding or a weak finish. |
| What stays with you? | The moments, emotions and discoveries you still remember after switching off. |
This is our editorial lens, not The Game Awards’ official scoring rubric. And it leaves room for disagreement. Some players want mastery and precision. Others want immersion, freedom or a story they can’t forget. That’s why arguing about games is half the fun.
Could GTA 6 change our minds? Of course.
We’re writing on November 17. Most people haven’t played GTA VI yet. Anyone pretending to have a complete public verdict on its quality is getting ahead of themselves.
Maybe Rockstar will deliver the game that outdoes all six rivals. Maybe it will be enormous, endlessly entertaining and just slightly less focused than its competitors. Either way, we’ll have to judge what’s actually there.
If you don’t feel like joining the GTA rush, that’s fine too: here are 20 games worth playing instead of GTA 6.
Pylcrow’s verdict
Our heart is with Resident Evil 9. Zelda is our timeless contender. Phantom Blade Zero is our wildcard.
We don’t want GTA VI punished for being popular or ambitious. We just don’t want popularity and ambition mistaken for automatic superiority.
Game of the Year shouldn’t necessarily go to the game that gives us the most things to do. It should go to the one that does the most with the experience it creates.
That’s our call heading into December 10. Now it’s the games’ turn to make the argument.
Quick answers
What games are nominated for GOTY at The Game Awards 2026?
Grand Theft Auto VI, Resident Evil Requiem, The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, Phantom Blade Zero, CONTROL Resonant and 007 First Light.
Did Resident Evil 9 already win Game of the Year?
Yes — Ultimate Game of the Year at the 2026 Golden Joystick Awards. The Game Awards’ GOTY winner will be announced separately on December 10.
Why was GTA 6 nominated before its release?
The Game Awards’ eligibility cutoff is November 20, 2026. GTA VI’s November 19 release fits that rule, and jury outlets may have had advance access to review it.
How is The Game Awards winner chosen?
The main awards use a blended result: 90% jury vote and 10% public vote. Read the official FAQ and voting rules.
Are remakes allowed to win Game of the Year?
Yes. Remakes and remasters are eligible when their new creative and technical contributions are judged worthy by the jury.
When will The Game Awards 2026 winner be announced?
At the ceremony on Thursday, December 10, 2026, at the Peacock Theater in Los Angeles.
Read next: Resident Evil 9’s Golden Joystick victory · GTA 6’s nomination before launch · Phantom Blade Zero review roundup · Ocarina of Time remake changes · More Pylcrow gaming coverage.
Sources: Gematsu (2026 nominees, November 17); The Game Awards official FAQ (rules, voting and eligibility); Dot Esports (Golden Joystick voting breakdown); GameSpot (historical GOTY winners); IO Interactive (007 First Light); Remedy Entertainment (CONTROL Resonant). The nominees, dates and voting mechanics are documented facts; our rankings, criteria and GTA debate are editorial opinions as of November 17, 2026.

