Hot TopicsVideo Games

Mafia: The Old Country Review — I Love This Game, and Not Because It’s Perfect

Smart summary

Yes, Mafia: The Old Country is worth playing if you value cinematic storytelling, Sicilian atmosphere and a focused single-player campaign. We love it despite repetitive combat, rigid stealth and limited sandbox freedom. The 2025 Free Ride update and 2026 Man of Honor expansion now add more to enjoy after the original story.

I love Mafia: The Old Country. And no, it isn’t because it’s the biggest, most innovative or most mechanically complicated game you can play. Quite the opposite. This is the kind of game that reminds us why a strong setting, characters worth following and a story with a beginning and an end can still be more satisfying than a gigantic map full of things to do.

That doesn’t mean it’s perfect. The stealth can be rigid, knife fights return too often, and the world is more convincing to look at than to interact with. Those criticisms are fair. They also miss something about why this particular game has such appeal: Hangar 13 chose to make a focused Sicilian crime drama rather than another game that asks to occupy your entire life.

Our verdict: Highly recommended for people who want to inhabit a story, not endlessly grind a world. The game’s strengths and limits are almost inseparable. This is a spoiler-light, enthusiast’s review, not a claim that everyone must agree.

Sunlit Sicilian coastal architecture in Mafia The Old Country
Sicily is the star of the show as much as Enzo is. Official 2K / Hangar 13 screenshot.

Is Mafia: The Old Country worth playing in 2026?

Yes — especially if you love old-fashioned, narrative-driven single-player games. The Old Country released in August 2025 on PS5, Xbox Series X|S and PC. It takes us to early-1900s Sicily and introduces Enzo Favara, a young man escaping brutal labor in the sulfur mines who is brought into Don Torrisi’s crime family. It is a story about the seduction of belonging, and what happens when the price of being accepted keeps rising.

The game is relatively compact: critics commonly describe the main campaign as around 12 to 15 hours, depending on pace. Don’t read that as a warning. For the right audience, a focused dozen hours beats forty hours of distraction. That’s the value proposition Hangar 13 openly defended before launch: a polished, complete story rather than an endlessly expanding checklist.

For some players, that will be a limitation. For us, it’s a welcome choice.

The setting: Sicily isn’t wallpaper

Think of the first three Mafia games and you remember American cities, slick suits, neon, jazz, bars, car chases and organized crime at different historical moments. The Old Country strips away much of that mythology. Instead, we’re surrounded by rural roads, stone towns, vineyards, coastal buildings, horses, early motorcars and a society where someone’s name can protect them — or destroy them.

It is a place that feels lived-in, not simply a set of missions. Hangar 13 consulted Sicilian historians and local partners; game director Alex Cox described Sicily as central to the story rather than merely an attractive backdrop. The textures, architecture and sound design make Enzo’s world distinctive before anyone explains the politics.

There’s a telling tension here: this may be one of the loveliest places Mafia has ever built, yet the campaign rarely allows you to treat it like a playground. You can resent that restriction and still be absorbed by the place. We are.

Atmospheric stone crypt in Mafia The Old Country
Enzo moves through a meticulously designed old-world environment. Official 2K gameplay image.

Enzo Favara is the right kind of protagonist for this story

Enzo doesn’t arrive as an untouchable boss. He enters as someone who has known powerlessness and sees a family that appears to offer dignity, safety and the chance to be somebody. That is the hook. Not a promise that the audience will be surprised by every plot turn, but the question of how far a person will go for a life he couldn’t previously imagine.

Don Torrisi, his advisers and the people around Enzo give that choice stakes. There is loyalty, ambition, mentorship, jealousy and romance — familiar gangster ingredients, absolutely. But familiarity isn’t automatically a failure. Plenty of great crime dramas use the same ingredients. The execution and atmosphere determine whether those ingredients matter.

The Old Country is not a revolutionary piece of crime fiction. It is a committed version of a classic one. And it asks something uncomfortably simple: when someone finally offers you the respect you’ve never had, how do you know what you’ve agreed to give away?

Don Torrisi discussing business in Mafia The Old Country
Don Torrisi’s authority defines the world Enzo wants to enter. Official 2K screenshot.

Why the linear format works — and when it doesn’t

One of the most interesting debates around this game is what people mean when they call its design “dated.” VGC admired the concentrated story and gorgeous Sicilian world. GameSpot praised its setting and performances but found the world and mechanics too shallow. Both reactions can be true.

Mechanically, you spend much of the campaign driving or riding, sneaking, fighting and shooting through designed set pieces, then returning to cinematic storytelling. Missions do not always reward improvisation. Stealth sections can punish mistakes harshly. Knife duels, memorable at first, risk feeling like a formula when repeated.

Here is where I land: I don’t want every game to become an open-world lifestyle. But if you’re going to make a linear game, variety within the missions matters even more. A great film can survive a familiar scene because the scene’s emotional purpose changes. A game needs that, too, through mechanics as well as dialogue. The Old Country occasionally falls short there.

Still, a game’s mechanical limits shouldn’t erase its achievements in pacing, atmosphere and storytelling. The equation is bigger than a list of activities.

What changed after the original 2025 reviews?

This matters if you’re reading older reviews in 2026. Many were written before the game expanded. In November 2025, 2K released Free Ride, a free update that brought more challenges and racing, a photo mode, Classic Difficulty, first-person driving and the black-and-white Cinema Siciliano mode. In August 2026, the paid Man of Honor expansion added two story chapters involving young Ennio Salieri, plus new Free Ride activities.

Do these additions turn The Old Country into the kind of fully reactive open world you’d find in a sandbox game? No. 2K itself says Free Ride is primarily additional gameplay and doesn’t directly alter Enzo’s main story. But they give people who enjoy the setting more reasons to remain there after the credits — and that’s a better answer than pretending the original campaign was something it wasn’t.

Cinema Siciliano black-and-white image mode in Mafia The Old Country
Cinema Siciliano was added in the free 2025 update, bringing an old-film aesthetic to the game. Official 2K screenshot.

The reviews were mixed. Here’s why I still love it.

At the time of writing, Metacritic’s PC page displays a critic score of 73 from 81 reviews, with a user score of 7.6. That’s neither a universal critical triumph nor a disaster. It reveals a difference in what people were hoping the game would be.

CriticismWhy it’s fairWhy it may not ruin the experience
It’s too linearYou have limited freedom during story missions.A tightly directed mob drama can feel intentional and well paced.
Combat repeatsStealth, shooting and knife duels have limited mechanical variety.The character drama and setting can carry you through familiar actions.
The story is predictableIt uses recognizable gangster conventions.Strong performances can make a familiar tragedy feel human.
The world isn’t fully interactiveIt often feels more like a film set than a reactive sandbox.Its visual identity is unusually rich, and Free Ride offers extra time in it.

There’s no contradiction in loving a game and agreeing with its harshest reviews on individual points. That is often how personal favorites work. They give you something you care about strongly enough that their imperfections stop being the only thing you see.

The little decision I’d recommend: try the Sicilian voices

The game includes a Sicilian-language dialogue option, and that is worth experimenting with if you enjoy subtitled foreign-language movies. It can make a setting feel less like an American gangster movie translated into another location. The option isn’t mandatory; the performances work in other supported languages too. But given how closely the team worked with regional collaborators on the atmosphere, the Sicilian audio fits the game’s ambitions.

Is it better than GTA? That’s the wrong question

Grand Theft Auto and Mafia share crime and driving, but they chase very different pleasures. GTA sells the fantasy of freedom: a city you can interrupt, a system you can provoke, a thousand distractions. The Old Country sells a directed journey: a particular person, a particular place and a decision that follows him.

One game asks what can I do in this world? The other asks what happens to this person in this world? We need both. In fact, the popularity of giant maps may be why an intimate game feels refreshing rather than limited. A world doesn’t need to be endless to leave a mark.

If you’re looking for sprawling games, see our 20 games to play instead of GTA 6. If you’re looking for more story-driven experiences, Mafia should be part of the conversation.

Gunfight scene from Mafia The Old Country early 1900s Sicily
Combat is grounded in older firearms and close-range confrontations, though mission variety can be limited. Official 2K gameplay image.

Who should play Mafia: The Old Country — and who shouldn’t?

Play it if…Think twice if…
You love gangster films, historical settings and concise campaigns.You want a giant reactive city with endless side missions.
You value performances, music and cinematic direction.You need stealth and combat systems that evolve constantly.
You like the story-first style of Mafia and Mafia II.You are looking for a deep RPG or a multiplayer game.

What’s next after you finish the story?

First, consider Man of Honor if you want more Enzo and an explicit connection to Don Salieri’s early life. Then play Mafia: Definitive Edition to follow the American story decades later. We have an entire Mafia timeline explainer that puts the games and the new DLC in chronological order without spoiling the main plot.

Mafia The Old Country Man of Honor expansion official key art
Man of Honor adds two new story chapters and connects Enzo with a young Ennio Salieri. Official 2K / Hangar 13 art.

Pylcrow’s final verdict

Mafia: The Old Country doesn’t need to be defended as a flawless game. I love it because it commits to being a particular kind of game. It gives us the dangerous beauty of Sicily, a protagonist trying to escape powerlessness and a criminal family that makes belonging feel like both a gift and a trap. The story may follow familiar gangster territory; the world and performances make that territory worth visiting.

I’d rather have more complete, confident single-player crime dramas like this than see every studio chase the largest map, the longest checklist and the most hours logged. Give me a great dozen hours. Give me a sense of place. Give me characters with something to lose.

And when a game gets those things right, I’ll happily forgive a knife fight or two too many.

Frequently asked questions

How long is Mafia: The Old Country?

Expect roughly 12 to 15 hours for the story, varying by difficulty and play style. Free Ride and the paid expansion add activities beyond the base campaign.

Is Mafia: The Old Country open world?

Its main campaign is linear and story-focused. The separate Free Ride mode allows exploration and additional challenges, but it isn’t a fully reactive sandbox.

Do I need to play Mafia 1 or Mafia 2 first?

No. Hangar 13 designed Enzo’s Sicilian story as an accessible entry point, with connections that reward returning players.

Is the Man of Honor expansion out?

Yes. It released August 14, 2026, adding two story chapters involving young Ennio Salieri.

What platforms is the game on?

PS5, Xbox Series X|S and PC via Steam, according to 2K.

Should I play in English or Sicilian?

Both are valid. If you are comfortable reading subtitles, try the Sicilian-language voices for additional atmosphere.

More to explore on Pylcrow

Read how Mafia: The Old Country fits in the full series timeline, browse our Video Games coverage, or check out our alternatives to GTA 6 for other games that value different experiences.

Sources and review context: 2K launch announcement; Hangar 13 director interview; VGC review; GameSpot review; Metacritic review aggregation; 2K Free Ride update; 2K Man of Honor expansion announcement; developer interview on Sicilian voice recording. Editorial assessment November 17, 2026.

Pylcrow

Pylcrow is the byline of this independent publication, covering film, TV, music, games, money and real-world mysteries. Every story separates what is documented from what is only claimed, links to its sources, and follows our published editorial policy. AI tools help with research and drafting; the choices and opinions are ours. Spot a mistake? Tell us through our corrections page and we will fix it.