Hot TopicsMovies & TV

Sunrise on the Reaping Reviews Are Divided. Did The Hunger Games Need Another Prequel?

Smart summary

The first reviews of The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping are mixed rather than unanimously positive or negative. Critics praise Joseph Zada and the return to Panem’s political anger, while others argue the story repeats familiar franchise beats. This is a review roundup, not Pylcrow’s own viewing review.

Panem has a strange business model: every few years it convinces us to buy another ticket to watch children forced into its arena. That may be precisely the point of the story. But as Sunrise on the Reaping approaches its November 20, 2026 US theatrical release, critics are disagreeing about whether the newest prequel says something new.

Lionsgate teaser artwork for The Hunger Games Sunrise on the Reaping
Official Lionsgate promotional artwork for Sunrise on the Reaping.

Are Sunrise on the Reaping reviews good?

They are divided. The Rotten Tomatoes first-reviews roundup highlights positive notices alongside concerns about an overcrowded plot and repetition. The Guardian’s review is markedly negative, while Time Out is far more enthusiastic.

What are reviewers praising?

Several responses single out Joseph Zada’s young Haymitch as a compelling anchor for the prequel. Positive reviews see the story renewing the franchise’s anger at spectacle, propaganda and the dehumanizing systems that make the games possible. The connection to Woody Harrelson’s older Haymitch gives this movie something special: viewers already know the survivor, but not the young man he used to be.

What are critics complaining about?

The negative argument is serious. A return to the Quarter Quell may feel familiar after five previous films. Critics who think the movie is bloated or overloaded with franchise references ask whether recognizability is being substituted for discovery. Screen Daily questions its character development, while Variety describes a watchable but meandering structure.

Why this particular prequel matters

The story centers on the Second Quarter Quell, 24 years before Katniss enters the arena. Two things matter more than any Easter egg. First, the Capitol turns terror into national entertainment. Second, surviving the spectacle doesn’t mean surviving its consequences. That is exactly the sort of material the Hunger Games films can still explore without becoming empty nostalgia.

Pylcrow’s take: the real question is whether Panem can still surprise us

We want the film to work. But a familiar franchise cannot demand praise just for returning. A prequel should make the films we already love feel different, not merely explain how a familiar character got his scars. If Sunrise can do that, returning to Panem is justified. If not, it is simply the Capitol running the show again—and we are the audience it knows how to sell to.

Read next: do you need to watch earlier Hunger Games films? · should you read the book first? · our Hunger Games films ranking.

Verified sources (checked November 19, 2026): Rotten Tomatoes first reviews; Time Out review; Screen Daily review; Lionsgate film trailer.

Pylcrow

Pylcrow is the byline of this independent publication, covering film, TV, music, games, money and real-world mysteries. Every story separates what is documented from what is only claimed, links to its sources, and follows our published editorial policy. AI tools help with research and drafting; the choices and opinions are ours. Spot a mistake? Tell us through our corrections page and we will fix it.